Automatic transmissions have come a long way. Once dismissed by driving purists and old-school mechanics, modern automatic gearboxes are now packed with technology that makes them smooth, efficient, and incredibly reliable. But despite their widespread use, myths about automatics still circulate. Let’s set the record straight by debunking seven of the most common misconceptions.
1. Automatic Transmissions Are Less Fuel Efficient Than Manuals
This used to be true—back when automatics relied on older torque converter technology. Today, however, modern automatic transmissions, such as those from Allison Transmission, can include the likes of CVTs and dual-clutch systems, making them just as fuel-efficient as manual transmissions, if not better.
Manufacturers have fine-tuned automatics to shift at the optimal time, reducing wasted fuel. Some models even come with additional fuel-saving features like adaptive learning, which adjusts shifting patterns based on driving habits.
Bottom line: Automatics can match or exceed manual transmissions in fuel efficiency, depending on the model.
2. Automatics Are More Expensive to Maintain and Repair
Many people assume that because automatics are more complex, they automatically (pun intended) cost more to maintain and repair. While it’s true that transmission repairs can be costly, regular maintenance significantly reduces the risk of major failures.
Modern automatic transmissions are designed to last, and many don’t even require servicing for extended periods. In contrast, manual transmissions require clutch replacements, which can be costly depending on the vehicle.
Preventative maintenance—such as fluid changes—keeps automatic transmissions running smoothly without breaking the bank.
3. You Can’t Tow With an Automatic
Some drivers believe that towing with an automatic is a bad idea, thinking the extra strain will ruin the transmission. However, most modern automatics are built to handle towing just as well as, if not better than, manual transmissions.
Many vehicles come with tow/haul modes that adjust shift points to reduce strain, preventing overheating and excessive wear. Some automatics even have better torque management, making them ideal for towing heavier loads.
Just follow manufacturer guidelines on towing capacity and transmission cooling, and an automatic will serve you just fine.
4. Automatics Are Slower and Less Fun to Drive
While early automatic transmissions had slower shift times, modern automatics—especially dual-clutch and sport-tuned versions—offer lightning-fast gear changes. Some automatics now shift quicker than a professional driver could with a manual transmission.
Additionally, many automatics feature paddle shifters or manual modes, allowing drivers to take control when they want a more engaging experience.
Today’s automatics can be just as thrilling as a manual, with the added bonus of effortless shifting in traffic.
5. They Don’t Last as Long as Manuals
Durability largely depends on maintenance and driving habits, not just transmission type.
Modern automatic transmissions are designed to last hundreds of thousands of kilometres with proper care. Advanced materials, better fluid technology, and computerised control systems help automatics manage wear and tear efficiently.
Meanwhile, manual transmissions rely on clutch replacements, which can add up over time. In some cases, a well-maintained automatic may even outlast a poorly driven manual.
Take care of an automatic, and it will take care of you.
6. You Can’t Push-Start a Car With an Automatic
This one is actually true—but it’s not a downside for most modern drivers.
Push-starting (or bump-starting) a manual transmission car is possible when the battery is dead, but with automatics, this isn’t an option because they require hydraulic pressure to engage gears. However, modern cars are equipped with reliable starters, jump-starting is easy, and roadside assistance is widely available.
It’s a rare situation, and for most people, the benefits of an automatic outweigh the slim chance of needing a push start.
7. Automatic Transmissions Are Only for Lazy or Inexperienced Drivers
This myth couldn’t be further from the truth. Automatic transmissions are designed for convenience, efficiency, and performance—not as a crutch for inexperienced drivers.
Many professional race cars, high-performance sports cars, and even heavy-duty trucks now use automatic or semi-automatic transmissions because they provide better control, quicker shifts, and improved reliability under extreme conditions.
Choosing an automatic isn’t about laziness—it’s about embracing modern technology that makes driving easier and more efficient.
Final Thoughts: Automatics Have Earned Their Place
The old myths about automatic transmissions no longer hold up. Thanks to advancements in engineering, they now rival manuals in performance, efficiency, and durability. Whether you’re driving in the city, towing a trailer, or enjoying a spirited drive, a modern automatic transmission has plenty to offer.
If you’ve been avoiding automatics due to outdated beliefs, it might be time to rethink your stance.